Didn't we all kind of expect this kind of video from all the 'clips' of advertisements? Something in the realm of "Jump" video? I knew it wouldn't be anything THAT spectacular, so I'm not that disappointed. Would of loved to have seen a full on production video like "Express Yourself" "Vogue" "Don't Tell Me" etc.
Also, yes, that was Lourdes joining in towards the end of the video dancing with all the dancers. Maybe the other version will feature her with the Virgin dress.
Without Benassi, this would stink pretty bad. It's made very well, but I would have liked a more elaborate setup. That probably couldn't happen with the tour going on. Madonna looks so good, though. And Lourdes is so flexible!
Wow, I can't believe how much I like this. Finally, a video with the production quality of one of her tour backdrop videos. I was expecting something like GI2M--
Let's see your 50yo mom pull off writhing like that... in that outfit!
Not all 51 years old mothers are desperate attention whores like Madonna, so it's unlikely they would end up embarrassing themselves like Vadge in this sad video...
i totally dig this mix and the video is amazing...it's just simple as one fan has put it. lola and mum looks fierce!
can't wait for the other video edits...
...wow, i can't believe some loser above would take the time to find a madonna site and write a bunch of bull. he sounds like a mimoo (aka mariah scary) fan. lol. what a douche! haha.
I'm so FUCKING OVER the SHIT you PEOPLE SAY ABOUT MADONNA!!!
Madonna is FANTASTIC! Just because she's 50, doesn't give you the right to slam her like that. I'm so SICK of all this negative SHIT that goes on. You can all just fuck off! Why the FUCK are you on this site if all you do is say shit about her? GET FUCKED! Find something better to do with your life.
Haha, in Lola's part Madonna is TOTALLY concentrated, lol! So is Lola, just before and after her bak flip thing. Jesus and the dancers are great. But WTF, is Madonna fucking everything in Jesus's part?! Miss the fans though :S
People have the right to state their opinion, whether it's a positive one or not. And if they're not being respectful about it, then that's bad, but what you're doing isn't any better. It's just annoying.
Paul: You're awesome. You always were and always will be. Thank you for everything. <3
"One question: Why is she always falling down at the end of the video? She did it in Hung Up, in Give It 2 Me and again in Celebration"
EXACTLY, bitch's not even trying anymore... and all of you ass kissers need to pull your tongue out of Madonna's asshole, she doesn't care bout you, me or anybody else.
You sound like the YES people who work for her, only difference is that you're not in her payroll, losers.
I've been a Flamboyant Homosexual Madonna fan for my whole life and after this musical travesty Celebration Video and the Fucking Nerve of Madonna not making Lola wear the Virgin dress I suffered a nervous break down. How dare Madonna do this to us!!!!!!!!!!
I don't think its Madonna's responsibility as an artist to give her fans a glimpse of her daughter dressed up like her in one of her music videos...in fact I sort of think it's creepy.
Like this edit of the song better actually, its harder and less of an obvious techno club sound. The other edit sounds exactly like the remix of WIFLFAG (again from the video).
Love the reactions of the trolls on here. Anyhow, I like the Benassi remix and think its the only good thing about the song. As for the video, its nothing new but its fun and I love when Madonna humps the air. Always fun to watch.
Madonna has been a low class dirty[ used to be smelly way back before her first single][ in fact we used to call her 'Smelly Louise'] phony stupid whore. She is shameless ,controlling , and hard working and that is the only reason she has made it. That talentless slut won't let her children watch TV but she lets her daughter be in this video. What a hypocrite. When is she going to go away? I have been waiting for decades! Well at least now we all have a forum to make fun of the ugly old piece of grizzle. But seriously although I pity Lourdes I really can't handle an off spring trying to hawk herself a career. What was Guy Ritchie ever thinking.? The diseases must run rampant in her cooch! God knows they did 20 and 30 years ago.
I guess madonna can only dance when she is holding onto a wall because recently in a photo shoot she was in a corner holding on too. it must make it easy for the photographers and directors to bounce white light on her oldness. I am no spring chicken myself but I have had zero work done and have meat on my bones and don't walk around drenched in white light fingering myself. I still have young dopey boys like Jesus following me around. Only difference is I was well raised and am a Mother of a daughter Lourdes age and am not a pathetic fame whore!
This old hag is one of the biggest morons ever. She claims she and her children do not watch TV, yet she puts her daughter in this stupid video? Ego maniac to say the least.
I saw this earlier this morning and it was one big snore fest. My 15 year old son was grossed out and thought she looked stupid doing that chicken waddle dance. Creepy.
Hate all you want, but I've never had hot legs like that, even when I was 21. These days most younger women aren't even taking care of themselves, and tend to be fat or obese. Also, I don't know any woman her age that look anywhere near that good. The only thing I hate is her recycled music, same beat different lyrics, where did her good music writers go?
wow this is actually very sad, that at 51yo and after all her success she still has to leverage her crotch to command attention. I read somewhere this song was supposed to be the new "Holiday" - I say big FAIL. Sounds as bad and generic as any other record she has put out on the last 15 years. Someone asked what happened to the good song writers she used to have...she ate some of them for lunch and alienated those who survived and they no longer want to work with her...she is a user that moves on quickly...plain and simple.
Plus, she can't even reinvent herself anymore. She hasn't come up with a distinctive look in a long time (unless you count the cheek implants as a new look). Guess there is nothing else in pop culture that she hasn't ripped off already.
And is this her own sneaky way to launch Lourdes' career as a video ho and train her to slowly take her place? Gasp!
Madonna was easily one of the most influential artists of my time. It's sad that she's turned into such a boring cunt. Everything after "Ray of Light" was an abysmal mess.
I understand that Madonna is aging, she is 51 and she's desperately trying to recapture her youth, and she is doing everything to look younger. But those cheekbone implants are horrendous. Her plastic surgeon should be ashamed of himself.
Remix is awesome. I hate the video for the same reason I hate the Cher videos-- a female superstar shouldn't lower herself to sharing the screen with under-30 nobodies to prove that she's relevant. It just looks sad.
Lolita wants to be Madonna, part deux, doesn't she? You'd have thought seeing an older woman losing it completely up close would put you off but apparently not.
I didn't pay any attention to the song because of all her epileptic fingering. Sad to see an ex-idol of mine going down like this. Someday she and Cher will have a Geriatric Grind-Off in Vegas.
interesting how the video is all done in some sort of white light filter or whatever the fuck is used, so her bizarre portruding muscle lumps and veins arent noticeable. If only she could appear that way in real life
First off, I cant stand Madonna. She is just not the right age to be acting like a skanked up slut...it reminds of those lonely old ladies you see in Vegas smoking cigs at the local bar.
She sure doesn't have dance skills. She always had the same boot moves and this video reminds me of the one where she's dressed like a Geisha.. "Nothing really matters" was the song, I think. Song is flat as hell. She has lost her thing.
I just feel bad for her daughter. Imagine being a young teen and this is your mother - fake humping guys on videos, and making out with a guy young enuf to be her son?
All the age phobic, sex phobic, nobody's that are posting on here are obviously getting their buttons pushed real hard by this video. Guess the old madge is still around. They also obviously do not listen to any electronic music. Yeah, it's not one of her best video's but will work quite well in a dance club. I actually enjoy it more than any of the video's from the Hard(ly) Candy album. Looking forward to the other edits with the album version.
Seriously... enough with the age-phobia! I am 25 and I hope I look half that good when I am 50.
"Once you reach a certain age, you're not allowed to be adventurous, you're not allowed to be sexual. I mean, is there a rule? Are you supposed to just die? I've never been a conformist." La Madonna
Funny how the SAME old bitter fag is posting most of these hateful posts on here!!!!! You hate Madonna so much that you STILL follow her career and have to come back every 10 mins to post another one of your crazy rants! SAD.
Really, I can understand people hating her music her style or Madonna herself just because she breathes but hating Vadge for her age? People who complain about her 50 year old ass gyrating are the same peeps who were creaming themselves because Wacko Jacko was about to fondle himself on stage not once but fifty times. What made MJ so special? Was it because he had a bleached wiener? The sexy pedo shtick? Now don't even think about telling me how "talented" Jacko was. I'm talking age here...
I've said it once, and I'll say it again...she should've stuck to her "Ray of Light" days...that album was flawless. How she goes from singing about philosophy and spirituality to trying to recapture her "Like a Virgin" days is fucking beyond me and further proves she's going through a major public midlife crisis. It took a downhill turn after that.
Poor Lourdes...she's a very beautiful girl and I hope to God that she doesn't turn out to be a dangerous egomaniac like her mother and starts buying babies.
What's really funny to me is that a hot piece of ass like Jesus would never in a million years give the time of day to this old bitch if she wasn't famous and loaded. He would tell a "regular" 50 year old woman to "fuck off". Guaranteed.
Criticism is great, and this video certainly earns it's share. But there's a difference between criticism and blind hate.
Either they're all from the same person or that person gave this link to an email list of fellow haters. Unusual to see so many angry, derogatory posts on one page...but then anytime anything is on YouTube the hate factor inflates dramatically.
I think Madonna sounds great on this new track, although overall I think both "edits" are too clubby and not pop enough for my tastes. I like this edit the better of the two.
It will be interesting to see when she decides to let the bright lights cool off and show a bit of her age. So far that's only happened when she's being interviewed about serious topics. Maybe one day she will find a way to meld her grown-up side to her sexy side, because no one ever said they had to mutually exclusive!
If she weren't "humping the air" the video would be called "tame," because she's Madonna. Now that she is, she's being called a whore. Well maybe a bit more subtlety would be nice, but she's nobody's whore. As far as her daughter's interest in performing, I think it's been made pretty clear that as she's grown up she's continued to show an interest of her own. For all we know NOT letting her be a part of the show could have been a big source of grief for Madonna. Basically, none of that is our business.
Haters sometimes bring up interesting points but only in a destructive way. Maybe we can just "discuss" their points of view and ignore the vitriol involved...
Wheres Lola? She's not in the viseo!
Love it!!!!!!
There is going to be several different ones 3 in total I believe I think Lola will be in the fan one to come out a lil later on.
She is! Shes in the colorful outfit towards the end and does the backflip! GO LOLA!!
No No No they said she will be in a wedding dress like Madonna's like a virgin.
This is the Benassi mix, is there gonna be a video of the actual radio mix, cos that mix is way better?!
What a load of shit. I hope the other edits are better and don't include Paul "The Frog" Oakenfold.
"No No No they said she will be in a wedding dress like Madonna's like a virgin."
LOL THATS HER!! Maybe she'll have the lav dress in the other version but thats Lola in the disco shirt!
Lola is in this version... oakenfold is not... frankly this is kinda crap. I was expecting something way better.
The editing is awesome! Really cool and poppin video. Love it!
Didn't we all kind of expect this kind of video from all the 'clips' of advertisements? Something in the realm of "Jump" video? I knew it wouldn't be anything THAT spectacular, so I'm not that disappointed. Would of loved to have seen a full on production video like "Express Yourself" "Vogue" "Don't Tell Me" etc.
Also, yes, that was Lourdes joining in towards the end of the video dancing with all the dancers. Maybe the other version will feature her with the Virgin dress.
I like the simplicity... less is more! She looks chic and the energy is really great (especially for the club, considering this edit is a remix).
Well, that was underwhelming... as expected (is that a good thing? that we no longer expect Madonna to deliver? shame)
It sure needs more Jesus Luz naked and less lame ass dancers...
Like it!! Thanks for sharing!!
Without Benassi, this would stink pretty bad. It's made very well, but I would have liked a more elaborate setup. That probably couldn't happen with the tour going on. Madonna looks so good, though. And Lourdes is so flexible!
Wow, I can't believe how much I like this. Finally, a video with the production quality of one of her tour backdrop videos. I was expecting something like GI2M--
Let's see your 50yo mom pull off writhing like that... in that outfit!
Not all 51 years old mothers are desperate attention whores like Madonna, so it's unlikely they would end up embarrassing themselves like Vadge in this sad video...
It's more like Lucky Star than GI2M
yeah, leaving negative comments on a fan site makes you an attention whore yourself. Using "wit" for a reaction... what a concept.
I have to say I don't really adore this mix. I love the radio mix! but still... AMAZING!! I absolutely love the video. love the parts with Jesus.
I just had a thought. It would have bee cool if Madonna was dancing with her dancers in the crowd and with her daughter.
I dislike this remix, and the video isn't very good either, but it's neither better nor worse than what I expected.
Oh well. To each their own. That's just my personal opinion, but I still hope she does well.
Haha, the part with Jesus is hilarious! xD
And Lola's part, aw so cute and humble.. Go out at be a dancer when you grow up.
Madonna’s daughter, who dresses like 80’s ‘Punky Brewster.’ Is the 1 who breaks out & does a back flip!
I miss you numbers
i totally dig this mix and the video is amazing...it's just simple as one fan has put it. lola and mum looks fierce!
can't wait for the other video edits...
...wow, i can't believe some loser above would take the time to find a madonna site and write a bunch of bull. he sounds like a mimoo (aka mariah scary) fan. lol. what a douche! haha.
MADONNA HAS DONE IT AGAIN! LOVE IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
All I can say is
FUCK ALL YOU HATERS!
I'm so FUCKING OVER the SHIT you PEOPLE SAY ABOUT MADONNA!!!
Madonna is FANTASTIC!
Just because she's 50, doesn't give you the right to slam her like that. I'm so SICK of all this negative SHIT that goes on. You can all just fuck off! Why the FUCK are you on this site if all you do is say shit about her? GET FUCKED! Find something better to do with your life.
Keep goin' hard Madonna!!!! Love you always :)
Haha, in Lola's part Madonna is TOTALLY concentrated, lol! So is Lola, just before and after her bak flip thing.
Jesus and the dancers are great. But WTF, is Madonna fucking everything in Jesus's part?!
Miss the fans though :S
her BEST VIDEO!
I love it. <3
Christian: STFU and quit trolling.
People have the right to state their opinion, whether it's a positive one or not. And if they're not being respectful about it, then that's bad, but what you're doing isn't any better. It's just annoying.
Paul: You're awesome. You always were and always will be. Thank you for everything. <3
I don't like, nothing new!!! it's similar to GIVE IT TO ME.... Some new idea it's important!!!!
OMG go GO LOLA!
I like it :) very madonna , great dancing and dancing ...a bit naughty ..just a fun video like the song , wasnt expecting a bad girl
she's gorgeous!!!
One question: Why is she always falling down at the end of the video? She did it in Hung Up, in Give It 2 Me and again in Celebration.
@ Jaap: I was thinking the exact same thing! :)
The video was and very hot watching Madonna devour her cub
"One question: Why is she always falling down at the end of the video? She did it in Hung Up, in Give It 2 Me and again in Celebration"
EXACTLY, bitch's not even trying anymore... and all of you ass kissers need to pull your tongue out of Madonna's asshole, she doesn't care bout you, me or anybody else.
You sound like the YES people who work for her, only difference is that you're not in her payroll, losers.
to the anomymous above:
FUCK OFF
i love the video... Madonna looks great, and her outfit is just gorgeous... and that Lola joined the dancing was real fun... she´s great. :)
I've been a Flamboyant Homosexual Madonna fan for my whole life and after this musical travesty Celebration Video and the Fucking Nerve of Madonna not making Lola wear the Virgin dress I suffered a nervous break down. How dare Madonna do this to us!!!!!!!!!!
how dare do this to us!!!! get a life...
Wow, people are getting so upset over some music video XD Madonna has made her job, cause good or bad, publicity IS publicity :P
at least we get two videos :)
I don't think its Madonna's responsibility as an artist to give her fans a glimpse of her daughter dressed up like her in one of her music videos...in fact I sort of think it's creepy.
Like this edit of the song better actually, its harder and less of an obvious techno club sound. The other edit sounds exactly like the remix of WIFLFAG (again from the video).
I wish this version of the song was the single/album version. Much more hard/cutting edged. Love the video too!
Love the reactions of the trolls on here. Anyhow, I like the Benassi remix and think its the only good thing about the song. As for the video, its nothing new but its fun and I love when Madonna humps the air. Always fun to watch.
Madonna has been a low class dirty[ used to be smelly way back before her first single][ in fact we used to call her 'Smelly Louise'] phony stupid whore. She is shameless ,controlling , and hard working and that is the only reason she has made it.
That talentless slut won't let her children watch TV but she lets her daughter be in this video. What a hypocrite. When is she going to go away? I have been waiting for decades! Well at least now we all have a forum to make fun of the ugly old piece of grizzle. But seriously although I pity Lourdes I really can't handle an off spring trying to hawk herself a career. What was Guy Ritchie ever thinking.? The diseases must run rampant in her cooch! God knows they did 20 and 30 years ago.
I guess madonna can only dance when she is holding onto a wall because recently in a photo shoot she was in a corner holding on too. it must make it easy for the photographers and directors to bounce white light on her oldness. I am no spring chicken myself but I have had zero work done and have meat on my bones and don't walk around drenched in white light fingering myself. I still have young dopey boys like Jesus following me around. Only difference is I was well raised and am a Mother of a daughter Lourdes age and am not a pathetic fame whore!
This old hag is one of the biggest morons ever. She claims she and her children do not watch TV, yet she puts her daughter in this stupid video? Ego maniac to say the least.
I saw this earlier this morning and it was one big snore fest. My 15 year old son was grossed out and thought she looked stupid doing that chicken waddle dance. Creepy.
Unoriginal - same stale cum stain shit we have come to know and loathe from Esther.
Bitch needs to go away now and realize no one wants to see her old twat bouncing around. Besides, one of these videos .. bitch is gonna break a hip.
Hate all you want, but I've never had hot legs like that, even when I was 21. These days most younger women aren't even taking care of themselves, and tend to be fat or obese. Also, I don't know any woman her age that look anywhere near that good. The only thing I hate is her recycled music, same beat different lyrics, where did her good music writers go?
wow this is actually very sad, that at 51yo and after all her success she still has to leverage her crotch to command attention. I read somewhere this song was supposed to be the new "Holiday" - I say big FAIL. Sounds as bad and generic as any other record she has put out on the last 15 years. Someone asked what happened to the good song writers she used to have...she ate some of them for lunch and alienated those who survived and they no longer want to work with her...she is a user that moves on quickly...plain and simple.
Plus, she can't even reinvent herself anymore. She hasn't come up with a distinctive look in a long time (unless you count the cheek implants as a new look). Guess there is nothing else in pop culture that she hasn't ripped off already.
And is this her own sneaky way to launch Lourdes' career as a video ho and train her to slowly take her place? Gasp!
Madonna was easily one of the most influential artists of my time. It's sad that she's turned into such a boring cunt. Everything after "Ray of Light" was an abysmal mess.
I can't wait either but I doubt Vadge would let Lourdes have the spotlight. There's only room for one superstar in that family.
I understand that Madonna is aging, she is 51 and she's desperately trying to recapture her youth, and she is doing everything to look younger. But those cheekbone implants are horrendous. Her plastic surgeon should be ashamed of himself.
JEsus's eyes are so fucking marble small and closely set. He looks wickedly stupid and it makes me want to donkey punch him.
Remix is awesome. I hate the video for the same reason I hate the Cher videos-- a female superstar shouldn't lower herself to sharing the screen with under-30 nobodies to prove that she's relevant. It just looks sad.
Lolita wants to be Madonna, part deux, doesn't she? You'd have thought seeing an older woman losing it completely up close would put you off but apparently not.
She looks more catlike than usual in the pictures from Israel. Scary to think what she'll look like after a few more procedures.
I didn't pay any attention to the song because of all her epileptic fingering. Sad to see an ex-idol of mine going down like this. Someday she and Cher will have a Geriatric Grind-Off in Vegas.
interesting how the video is all done in some sort of white light filter or whatever the fuck is used, so her bizarre portruding muscle lumps and veins arent noticeable. If only she could appear that way in real life
I love her but I have to say...Patsy Stone rides again!
FYI, there would be no Lady Gag-a if it were not for this fossil.
A 51 year old fingering and grinding to her techno music. Such a rebel Madge. Let it go Madge, let it go.
I don't think she could have gyrated any more in this video. It's like she's trying reaaaaaaal hard to be sexy. That's just Madonna I guess...
This song sounds like something I'd hear from a Pepsi commercial. Also there's no way Jeebus is fucking Madonna.
Oh, and I just loved the repeated shots of her finger herself, and rubbing her pussy.
This is what you have your children appear in, slut?
First off, I cant stand Madonna. She is just not the right age to be acting like a skanked up slut...it reminds of those lonely old ladies you see in Vegas smoking cigs at the local bar.
hahah The "Eat Your Heart Out Guy Ritchie" video, or the "Let me you raise your profile Baby Jesus" video? Either or, she's fucking garbage.
Why is she allowed to dine freely in Israel?
Don't the authorities mind that she continuely wipes her shit-stained anus across Jewish culture and trivialises the crucifixion of Christ?
Nice to see that Vadge continues to confuse her children by normalising the employment of a young man to replace their step-father.
And this old crow was deemed a reasonable parent by which adoption board exactly?
Same old lighting tricks to disguise the wrinkles and sun-damage I see.
We can hate all we want but the bitch looks hot for her age. My fucking legs dont look like that I am fucking 26!
Also, those boots are to die for.
Spaz-tastic! I think I am going into convulsions from watching it. Madonna looks like a horny old nursing home resident.
She sure doesn't have dance skills. She always had the same boot moves and this video reminds me of the one where she's dressed like a Geisha.. "Nothing really matters" was the song, I think. Song is flat as hell. She has lost her thing.
I just feel bad for her daughter. Imagine being a young teen and this is your mother - fake humping guys on videos, and making out with a guy young enuf to be her son?
she doesn't look as veiny as usual.
.. All of her music sounds the same
Something something.. yeeaaahh.. somethin yeah somethin... yeeaah
I'm torn. It's kind of a cool video, she looks good with her arms covered and glasses covering her implanted cheekbones.
But isn't it time for her to make a video that her children won't be embarrassed to watch?
All the age phobic, sex phobic, nobody's that are posting on here are obviously getting their buttons pushed real hard by this video. Guess the old madge is still around. They also obviously do not listen to any electronic music. Yeah, it's not one of her best video's but will work quite well in a dance club. I actually enjoy it more than any of the video's from the Hard(ly) Candy album. Looking forward to the other edits with the album version.
Seriously... enough with the age-phobia! I am 25 and I hope I look half that good when I am 50.
"Once you reach a certain age, you're not allowed to be adventurous, you're not allowed to be sexual. I mean, is there a rule? Are you supposed to just die? I've never been a conformist." La Madonna
thank god its not like a mariah carey's video.
Funny how the SAME old bitter fag is posting most of these hateful posts on here!!!!!
You hate Madonna so much that you STILL follow her career and have to come back every 10 mins to post another one of your crazy rants!
SAD.
Madonna was always controversial. She lost that move over the last years.
BUT she's back at it in FULL FORCE. Bravo!
I like the part where she fell and broke her hip at the end.
Really, I can understand people hating her music her style or Madonna herself just because she breathes but hating Vadge for her age? People who complain about her 50 year old ass gyrating are the same peeps who were creaming themselves because Wacko Jacko was about to fondle himself on stage not once but fifty times. What made MJ so special? Was it because he had a bleached wiener? The sexy pedo shtick? Now don't even think about telling me how "talented" Jacko was. I'm talking age here...
Writhing around, scratching and rubbing yourself like you have fleas, scabies and a yeast infection is "dancing"?
Madonna is ridiculous and her 'music' is boring.
Madonna is the poster whore for selling your soul for fame by f-ing everything on her way to the top.
Bitch can't sing worth a shit; doesn't play any instruments; and couldn't write a song on her own if you held Jesus' dick in front of her.
What a festering, puss filled sore on the ass of humanity.
I've said it once, and I'll say it again...she should've stuck to her "Ray of Light" days...that album was flawless. How she goes from singing about philosophy and spirituality to trying to recapture her "Like a Virgin" days is fucking beyond me and further proves she's going through a major public midlife crisis. It took a downhill turn after that.
Poor Lourdes...she's a very beautiful girl and I hope to God that she doesn't turn out to be a dangerous egomaniac like her mother and starts buying babies.
What's really funny to me is that a hot piece of ass like Jesus would never in a million years give the time of day to this old bitch if she wasn't famous and loaded. He would tell a "regular" 50 year old woman to "fuck off". Guaranteed.
some people are green...hehehe
Go MADONNA!!!
Now I know what this video reminds me of.. LUCKY STAR!!!
RE: haters
Criticism is great, and this video certainly earns it's share. But there's a difference between criticism and blind hate.
Either they're all from the same person or that person gave this link to an email list of fellow haters. Unusual to see so many angry, derogatory posts on one page...but then anytime anything is on YouTube the hate factor inflates dramatically.
I think Madonna sounds great on this new track, although overall I think both "edits" are too clubby and not pop enough for my tastes. I like this edit the better of the two.
It will be interesting to see when she decides to let the bright lights cool off and show a bit of her age. So far that's only happened when she's being interviewed about serious topics. Maybe one day she will find a way to meld her grown-up side to her sexy side, because no one ever said they had to mutually exclusive!
If she weren't "humping the air" the video would be called "tame," because she's Madonna. Now that she is, she's being called a whore. Well maybe a bit more subtlety would be nice, but she's nobody's whore. As far as her daughter's interest in performing, I think it's been made pretty clear that as she's grown up she's continued to show an interest of her own. For all we know NOT letting her be a part of the show could have been a big source of grief for Madonna. Basically, none of that is our business.
Haters sometimes bring up interesting points but only in a destructive way. Maybe we can just "discuss" their points of view and ignore the vitriol involved...